Things You Might Not Know About Cresskill, NJ

Cresskill, New Jersey, is one of Bergen County’s most charming and desirable suburban communities. Nestled along the banks of the Tenakill Brook and framed by a rich history, outstanding schools, and a strong sense of community, Cresskill is often praised for its peaceful ambiance and proximity to New York City. But beyond its reputation as a family-friendly town, Cresskill has its own unique character, stories, and attractions that even some locals may not know about.

Whether you're a longtime resident, considering a move, or just curious, this post explores the lesser-known side of Cresskill—its historical treasures, cultural highlights, and quirks that set it apart.

While Cresskill today is a modern suburb, it played a role in America’s earliest history. During the Revolutionary War, the area now known as Cresskill was part of a key corridor for George Washington’s troops. In fact, Washington’s army passed through Bergen County multiple times, using various routes to outmaneuver British forces.

Cresskill’s proximity to strategic river crossings and military encampments makes it quietly significant in Revolutionary history.

Even today, the echoes of that era can be felt in the older architecture and the preserved historical markers scattered around town and nearby communities.

Although Cresskill is its own municipality, it sits adjacent to several other towns that add to its charm. One hidden treasure for outdoor lovers is the Tenafly Nature Center, only a few minutes' drive away. This 400-acre preserve features hiking trails, a butterfly and pollinator garden, a serene pond, and various educational programs for children and adults alike.

Residents of Cresskill often enjoy these trails as an extension of their own backyard, making it a quiet but powerful perk of living in the area—especially for those who enjoy hiking, bird watching, or just escaping into nature without a long drive.

Just a stone’s throw from Cresskill is the Demarest Railroad Depot, a stunning architectural gem built in 1872. Though technically located in Demarest, the station’s preservation and historic presence resonate across the area, including Cresskill. Today, the building serves as an art gallery and event space, but it originally helped shape suburban commuting patterns and played a role in the growth of Bergen County.

The Depot is also an excellent example of the Romanesque Revival architectural style, showcasing the area’s dedication to maintaining historical landmarks and repurposing them for modern use.

Despite its relatively small population, Cresskill has been home to several notable figures, particularly from the entertainment and sports worlds. Thanks to its privacy, luxury real estate offerings, and quick commute to Manhattan, many celebrities and athletes have chosen to call this quiet suburb home at various career points.

While locals respect privacy, it’s not uncommon to see a familiar face at a local coffee shop or gym. This lends the town a bit of low-key glamour without the crowds or paparazzi of city life.

Many people outside the area might not know that Cresskill High School is consistently ranked among the top public high schools in New Jersey. The school excels not just in academics, but also in music, athletics, and STEM programs. With strong Advanced Placement offerings and a supportive community culture, Cresskill High prepares students for top-tier colleges while maintaining a close-knit learning environment.

The school’s success adds tremendous value to real estate in the area, making Cresskill a top choice for families who prioritize education.

While Cresskill is a relatively small town, it boasts a surprisingly diverse population. Residents come from a wide range of cultural and ethnic backgrounds, creating a welcoming environment where global traditions blend seamlessly into suburban life. From international restaurants and specialty grocery stores to community events that celebrate various cultures, Cresskill reflects nearby New York City's cosmopolitan nature while retaining its unique charm.

New residents often remark on the community's warmth, openness, and spirit of inclusion, making it a great place for people of all backgrounds to settle and thrive.

Though it doesn’t have the commercial sprawl of larger cities, Cresskill has a small but impressive collection of locally owned boutiques, cafes, and restaurants. Downtown Cresskill features an elegant blend of old and new—historic buildings housing stylish modern businesses, coffee shops with artisanal roasts, and family-owned eateries serving up everything from sushi to wood-fired pizza.

Locals love the town’s walkability and the sense of discovery that comes with finding a new hidden gem—be it a gourmet bakery, a wine bar, or a European-inspired home decor shop.

Many homebuyers choose Cresskill for one simple reason: location. It offers the best of both worlds—a serene, suburban lifestyle with quick access to the cultural, professional, and recreational opportunities of New York City. Whether you work in the city or just love taking in Broadway shows or dining downtown, living in Cresskill puts you within easy reach without sacrificing peace and quiet.

The town’s proximity to the George Washington Bridge, bus routes, and nearby train stations makes commuting feasible, even enjoyable—especially for those who appreciate coming home to a calm, green space.

Finally, one of Cresskill’s most beloved but lesser-known strengths is its community spirit. Seasonal festivals, farmers’ markets, charity events, and family movie nights are a regular part of life here. Whether it’s the Fourth of July parade, a winter tree lighting ceremony, or a local charity 5K, these gatherings bring residents together and foster the kind of neighborly connections that make a place feel like home.

It's not just about living in a nice house—it’s about feeling like you belong. And in Cresskill, that sense of belonging is real and thriving.

If you're considering a move to Bergen County and want a town that offers charm, character, top schools, and a deep sense of community, Cresskill deserves a spot at the top of your list. It combines history, natural beauty, cultural richness, and suburban comfort in one welcoming package.

Looking to learn more about homes for sale in Cresskill? The Kolsky Team is your trusted guide for navigating the Bergen County real estate market. With years of experience, insider knowledge, and a deep love for the community, The Kolsky Team can help you find the perfect home that fits your lifestyle.

Visit thekolskyteam.com to connect with Cresskill real estate experts who are ready to help you discover your new favorite town. Let’s find your perfect place in this hidden gem of New Jersey.